The biggest innovations in recruitment we’ve seen in recent years have involved AI. From systems that automate timesheet management to something as simple as proofreading emails for you, there’s a lot of ways to incorporate AI into your temporary recruitment agency.
However, there is one AI system that is very controversial. AI models are conducting virtual interviews with potential candidates, asking them all the questions and ‘listening’ to the answers in order to assess competency.
Today we’re going to talk about the pros and cons of AI interviewers, so you can decide if they are something you should invest in.
What are AI Interviewers?
AI interviews, as the name suggests, are interviews with candidates entirely run by an AI model. They usually take one of two forms; either a disembodied voice that candidates must respond to, or an AI-generated interviewer who will appear on screen in place of a real person.
In some ways, AI has been conducting interviews for a while. Temporary recruitment agencies may use an AI model to create a shortlist of candidates that they can send to their clients. This involves scanning their profiles and CVs, but some also contact the candidates and ask them questions.
Typing messages to an AI chatbot is nothing new, often they’re the way you receive online customer service, but speaking to one face to ai-generated-face is a step up.
The Benefits of AI Interviewers
Naturally, using an AI system to interview candidates saves human workers a lot of time. Even a few online interviews can take hours or even a full day depending on schedules, and you need to make sure the correct people are in the interview room, such as department managers.
AI can run all of these interviews simultaneously, while you focus on more important things. The technology involved is impressive too. Instead of just recording and processing what a candidate says, the system can also judge confidence from eye contact, how presentable they appeared, and how responsive they were to questions.
The questions themselves can be tailored to the candidate. Most will be generic, but the AI model can refer to specific parts of their profile and CV and ask a question about them.
As a time save, AI interviewers are worth considering. However, there are some serious downsides that need to be kept in mind.
The Issues with AI Interviewers
The main concerns regarding AI interviews have come from the candidates themselves. AI interviewers can make them uncomfortable, especially when they are audio only. An interview is a stressful time to begin with, adding an extra layer of difficulty can lead to a lot of frustration, and candidates won’t be at their best.
There are also some teething problems with the systems themselves. AI interviewers may interrupt candidates, not understand responses, or glitch out completely, leaving a blank screen or a disconnected call. If you’re a business owner trying to find a new hire, this doesn’t reflect well on your company, and for an agency, you won’t have a good indication of the candidate’s suitability.
An interview isn’t just for the employer’s benefit. It’s also the place for candidates to ask questions about the role, so they can decide if it suits them. AI interviewers struggle to answer questions posed by a candidate, and if they it’s usually information that is available on the job description, anything else is not something they can find out.
Are AI Interviewers Worth the Investment?
AI interviews are becoming more and more common, despite protests from jobseekers. If you weigh the pros and cons, the negatives are hard to ignore, but many businesses are investing in them regardless. Job roles are still being filled using this method, so clearly there is something to them.
Like a lot of AI systems, it’ll take more time to iron out the kinks. In a year, AI interviews may be the norm, and should be much better for the candidate thanks to upgrades in the technology.
For the time being, the systems are great for initial interviews. AI is at its best when paired with the human touch. If it conducts the first interview, and then a human does the second, you’ll get the best of both worlds and can still judge the candidate for yourself. After all, you know what’s best.
As a temporary recruitment agency, you need to assess the competency of dozens, sometimes hundreds of candidates per day. If you’re conducting interviews on behalf of your client, using AI must seem appealing. However, they may be doing more harm than good, so make sure that there’s a human also reviewing candidates before the shortlist is sent off.
Recruitment Funding with a Human Touch
At Back Office Support Services, we know the importance of investing in new technology. Temporary recruitment is an incredibly competitive and temperamental industry, so you can’t afford to ignore new technology that can streamline processes and help you get ahead.
But if there’s one thing we’ve learned over the last 30 years, it’s that there’s no alternative to the human touch. What sets us apart are the people behind the magic, who directly support our clients with regular reporting and an informal yet professional style that builds a great relationship.
So if you need any of the following…
…our all-in-one service will provide everything you need and more. If you get in touch with us, you won’t be greeted by an AI-generated voice. You’ll hear from a person who cares as much about your success as you do, and we’ll work together to streamline your agency.